Skip to main content

GUEST COLUMN: FAIR OR UNFAIR - WILL SONIA SOTOMAYOR BE AN LGBT FRIEND OR FOE?

This Ameriqueer guest column is by Ed Anderson of Royal Oak, MI about the pick of Sonia Sotomayor to replace moderate/liberal Justice Souter. We will be hearing a lot more about Sotomayor on Ameriqueer as her confirmation looms and we learn more of her views.

Fair or Unfair
By Ed Anderson

"A wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion" Sonia Sotomayor said in 2001, What does this say about a woman who wants to be on the Supreme Court of the United States? Will she be sensitive to all citizens or will she only find empathy with people, cases that she feels are moral?

There are no clear indications on how Sotomayor will vote on LGBT issues because there are no rulings in her career involving gay rights cases. However the Human Rights Campaign says “We are encouraged by several of Judge Sotomayor’s decisions which have recognized the Constitutional right to privacy, first articulated in Griswold v Connecticut where the Supreme Court first ruled on privacy, which lays the foundation for fundamental rights for LGBT people. We look forward to conducting a thorough examination of her record on privacy issues.” She did co-sign a letter to the editors of The Daily Princetonian on February 27, 1976 criticizing an anti-gay attack at Princeton. While encouraging, this is not nearly enough to determine what she would do if given the chance to interpret the law in the highest court of the land.

While a comment Sotomayor made, may seem to have been racially insensitive, the opposite may actually be true. Her position on gay issues may be unclear but she stuck up for gay men over thirty years ago and there is nothing to suggest that she wouldn’t do that again.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

In anti-gay attack, AIM falsely asserts "pedophile" Jennings was "teaching 14-year-old boys" about sexual practices | Media Matters for America

In anti-gay attack, AIM falsely asserts "pedophile" Jennings was "teaching 14-year-old boys" about sexual practices | Media Matters for America : "In attacking the media for allegedly insufficient coverage of Obama administration official Kevin Jennings, a blogger for Accuracy in Media, which purports to 'set the record straight on important issues that have received slanted coverage' -- and which has a record of antagonism toward gays -- smeared Jennings as a 'pedophile' and falsely claimed that '[v]ideos have surfaced of Jennings teaching 14-year-old boys the dangerous sexual practice of 'fisting,' and discussing with them the particulars of oral sex.' In fact, Jennings did not conduct that seminar and, in fact, reportedly criticized it when he became aware of its content." AIM is a crock. They're nothing more than Republican mouthpieces.

HEY #p2!--CALLING ALL PROGRESSIVE ALLIES!

-HEY #p2! (Progressives). We can't do this alone. Lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender Americans have been fighting for over half a Century to have basic Civil Rights. We have so much to do, and we are such a small group. Without an army of Progressive allies, we can't win. Our rights as American citizens are constantly being compromised, despite life-time service to our nation as good, contributing citizens. We can't wait any longer. We need our Progressive allies to step up and go to bat for us TODAY. We must demand Progressives have got to make LGBT rights a top priority in 2010, or we will keep being put on the back-burner. There will ALWAYS be something more important than LGBT equality affecting America--issues like Health Care Reform and the Economy effect LGBT people too! However, when we are discriminated against under the law every single day, we can't give our all to fixing these problems. We are long overdue to be counted as equal citize...

RECAP 0812-Harvey Milk #MI #IL #CA #FL #OK #WA RICK SANTORUM, LOVE WON OUT!

HERE'S YOUR PWA/LGBTQANEWS FOR THURSDAY JULY 30, 2009! FOR UP TO THE HOUR BREAKING LGBT NEWS, FOLLOW AMERIQUEER ON TWITTER : twitter.com/ameriqueer ! @ drjilliantweiss Please call today's #ENDA legislators MT Baucus, Tester http://bit.ly/jgwRR NEW ON AMERIQUEER FIRST, @ bilericoproject Governor Quinn saves most of Illinois AIDS/HIV budget http://bit.ly/M5bI9 #lgbt Please please read my Ameriqueer post on this http://bit.ly/19SlyL I hear MAINE is beautiful in fall! BRADLEY TRAYNOR'S BIG GAY NEWS FOR TODAY FIRST @ rainbownews Audio: President Obama bestowing Harvey Milk posthumous Medal of Freedom http://bit.ly/4PdLQ @ TheAdvocateMag ABA, NEA Come Out for Gay Rights http://bit.ly/ADUyM @ michaelajones Rick Santorum dips anti-LGBT toes into 2012 Presidential campaign http://tinyurl.com/ryb2rp ; @ JoeMyGod former Sen Santorum (R-Pa) Considering Presidential Bid http://bit.ly/1196hU OUR|ILLINOIS FIRST, @ WindyCityTimes1 LGBTI health summit in...